24 June, 2005

-image-for the record

I completely agree with Rebecca McKinnion on everything in her most recent post. Read the whole thing, but here are the bullet points:

1. I am not calling for a boycott of China or of Cisco or any other companies.
2. I am in favor of free trade, I support capitalism, and I think trading with China is a good thing.
3. I don’t think legislation or political lobbying is completely useless.

I developed the ‘censored by Cisco advertisment’ on the left-hand sidebar, more of which are available here (I do encourage copying), because I believe it is the best way to bring attention to the censorship situation in China. The Great Firewall is a creation of the Communist Party of China (CPC), and they are the ones who should be blamed. But every blogger in the world could post a banner condemning censorship in China and the CPC would not give a toss.

Every blogger in the world could have a banner photo of Tank Man and the CPC would not give a toss.

I’m not accusing Cisco, Juniper or Alcatel in being ‘knowingly
complicit’ in building the Great Firewall, but as they are instrumental
in constructing the state’s communication system. I believe that
calling upon them to explain themselves, and what they know, is a more
useful way to gain attention than calling on the CPC to defend itself.
Plus, as Rebecca argues:

I want to know if these
companies are providing service or customization which would make it
clear that they know exactly how those technologies are going to be
used - despite public claims of innocence and clean hands.
I
agree, China is better off - and the future of democracy in China is
better off - thanks to the existence of Cisco routers in China. But to
me, there is an important difference between selling routers to China
and providing software services to China in general - with the
understanding that one can’t control how the technology ultimately gets
used - and the sale of technology directly to Chinese government
entities whose intentions are rather obvious. Way back in 2001,
according to this report here by the International Centre for Human
Rights and Democratic Development, Cisco was courting the Chinese
Public Security bureau for business. Author Ethan Gutmann has reported
similar things. As have Amnesty International and the Open Net
Initiative. Cisco denies any direct involvement or knowledge in how its
products were going to be used. Nobody can 100% confirm anything. But
are we just going to take Cisco’s word for it and leave it at that?

by @ 8:22 am. Filed under Asia, Blogs, Censorship, China, East Asia, Northeast Asia, Web/Tech, Weblogs

4 Responses to “for the record”

  1. Hans on Experience Says:

    China has blocked all TypePad blogs!

    Oh my God. What a story this is. China has blocked all the TypePad blogs! I first read the blacklisted? story on Asiapundit yesterday. That was a questionmarkt then. Now it is certain. Rebecca MacKinnon:

  2. Hans on Experience Says:

    China has blocked all TypePad blogs!

    Oh my God. What a story this is. China has blocked all the TypePad blogs! I first read the blacklisted? story on Asiapundit yesterday. That was a questionmarkt then. Now it is certain. Rebecca MacKinnon:

  3. Hans on Experience Says:

    China has blocked all TypePad blogs!

    Oh my God. What a story this is. China has blocked all the TypePad blogs! I first read the blacklisted? story on Asiapundit yesterday. That was a questionmarkt then. Now it is certain. Rebecca MacKinnon:

  4. thehorsesmouth.blog-city.com Says:

    Typepad Block Lifted?

    After a week of being blacklisted in China, Typepad sites are now visible to prying eyes.

Leave a Reply


You must be logged in to post a comment.

[powered by WordPress.]

Free Hao Wu
Keep on Blogging!

Support Bloggers' Rights!
Support Bloggers' Rights!




Search Blog

 
Web AsiaPundit

Archives

June 2005
M T W T F S S
« May   Jul »
 12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
27282930  

Categories

China

Japan

  • Austin Arensberg
    0
  • Black China hand
    0
  • China Confidential
    0
  • China Digital Times (CDT)
    0
  • China e-Lobby
    0
  • China Matters
    0
  • The China Stock Blog
    0
  • Chinese Law Prof Blog
    0
  • Harvard Extended
    0
  • The Horse’s Mouth
    0
  • Isaac Mao
    0
  • serialdeviant.org(y)
    0
  • Shanghai Diaries
    0
  • Howard W French
    0
  • Metanoiac!
    0
  • Danwei
    0
  • supernaut …
    0
  • Bingfeng Teahouse
    0
  • Andrés Gentry
    0
  • sinosplice
    0
  • China Herald
    0
  • Wanbro
    0
  • Running Dog
    0
  • The Unabrewer
    0
  • Shenzhen Ren
    0
  • billsdue
    0
  • the Big Yuan
    0
  • Imagethief
    0
  • middle kingdom stories
    0
  • The LongBow Papers
    0
  • Mandate of Heaven
    0
  • Micah Sittig
    0
  • Survived SARS
    0
  • Under The Tenement Palm
    0
  • Talk Talk China
    0
  • The Paper Tiger
    0
  • T-salon
    0
  • Shanghaiist
    0
  • Wangjianshuo’s Blog
    0
  • Laowiseass
    0
  • Fear of a White Planet
    0
  • Hong Kong

    The Koreas

  • SuaraMalaysia.com
    0
  • Rajan
    0
  • American Expat in SE Asia
    0
  • Pok Ku
    0
  • TV Smith
    0
  • MacVaysia
    0
  • mental jog
    0
  • Screenshots…
    0
  • Nik Nazmi
    0
  • Britishasian
    0
  • Taiwan

  • NiHowdy
    0
  • a better tomorrow
    0
  • betelnutblogger
    0
  • IslaFormosa
    0
  • One whole jujuflop situation
    0
  • Naruwan Formosa
    0
  • Scott Sommers
    0
  • Formosa online
    0
  • Wandering to Tamshui
    0
  • Freedom Slopes
    0
  • Formosa online
    0
  • taiwan tiger 台灣的老虎
    0
  • India & South Asia

    Global & Regional

  • Mutant Frog
    0
  • Sushicam
    0
  • MasaManiA=道徳遊戯
    0
  • Nichi Nichi
    0
  • Tokyo Times
    0
  • Japan Window Photo Blog - Culture, Life, People & Pictures
    0
  • LDK
    0
  • The Tanuki Ramble
    0
  • Frog in a Well
    0
  • Japundit
    0
  • Miyakonojo
    0
  • Joi Ito’s Web
    0
  • The Old Revolution
    0
  • Renegades!
    0
  • Riding Sun
    0
  • Shamrocks!
    0
  • The White Peril 白禍
    0
  • Yagami-Sama
    0
  • Meta Data

    Locations of visitors to this page Listed on BlogShares Ecosystem Details

    Other

    sponsors



    AsiaPundit Friends

    Adopt


    Recommended


    Mr. China - by Tim Clissold:
    How to lose $400 million in the world's biggest market.


    Imelda - Power, Myth, Illusion:
    A documentary on the former Philippine first lady that is damning, sympathetic and incredibly funny.


    Yat Kha - Re Covers:
    Siberian throat-singing punk band searches for its roots


    5.6.7.8.'s - Bomb the Twist:
    Three Japanese women play 1950's-inspired punk.


    Gigantor Box Set Volume 1:
    The original giant Japanese robot


    Mao: The Unknown Story - by Jung Chang and Jon Halliday:
    A controversial and damning biography of the Helmsman.

    Recent Posts

    recent comments

    • tutubi: this is dardn true the 5 peso coins also smuggled out of the country to be melted :(
    • tutubi: you seem to pick up almost any news from here, eh? elections here are generally like that. Candidates (or...
    • Josh: mahathir_fan your an idiot.
    • Inst: don't get arrogant. once this comes to the attention of the authorities who says Opera Mini isn't going to get...
    • Chinese Girl: I think that you all are creeps who are nothing but plain jealous of China. If you think that China is...

    Sponsors

    singapore

    Malaysia

    Indonesia

    Phillippines

    Vietnam

    More from China

    42 queries. 1.108 seconds