4 July, 2005

-image-taiwan and us’ interests

A provocative item by Conagher78 argues against US involvement in a cross-strait conflict between China and Taiwan.:

And as far as alliances go, why not try harder to see to it that China
becomes an ally? The twin prongs of a ready defense (of which I am
still in favor regarding China and everyone else) and engagement were
sufficient to end the Soviets … is it no longer good enough to
encourage freedom and democracy in China? Are conservatives ready to
shrug off the lessons we learned from Ronald Reagan before his body is
even cold? In any event, do we not still have plenty of military assets
in Japan and South Korea? Japan has always been the knife at China’s
belly. The edge is razor sharp thanks to America’s presence on the
island. Sacrificing American lives to retain a position on the island
of Taiwan, so far from the political heart of China in Beijing, is
scarcely worth it.

Some interesting points are raised in the full item. However, while I think an attack on Taiwan by China is highly unlikely, US ambiguity on whether it would defend the island has long been a bulwark against any Chinese attack. I can’t imagine a Chinese assault on Taipei anytime soon - if ever - but a clear statement that the US would NOT defend Taiwan would surely increase risks to the island.

Beyond that, defending Taiwan would be defending democracy. I believe that, more than strategic interests, is the driver of the current US’ alliances with both Taiwan and Israel. That may not be strategically sound, but it is morally correct. If the US is to play a role in unification, it should be - above all - to assure that the democratic gains of Taiwan are respected.

Also at the site, a good fisking of Bill Gertz hyperbolic rantings on China’s imperialist ambitions.

by @ 2:34 pm. Filed under Asia, China, East Asia, Northeast Asia, Taiwan

One Response to “taiwan and us’ interests”

  1. Conagher Says:

    Thanks for the mention! I discovered your blog via another blog, I believe, and I like what I’ve read so far.

    As far as defending democracy goes, I think the US has to examine what national interest the democracy in question serves if such a defense were needed. Defending democracy is a noble goal, but it’s not one I am particulary eager to engage in with the lives of American soldiers without some other compelling reason. Seems to me that a) if the UN is to have a purpose, it’s handling these sorts of situations, and b) the US would indeed be acting as “world police,” which is a prospect at which the paleocon in me rebels.

    I do agree that the ambiguity of the One China policy has stabilized the Taiwan situation to some degree. Whether by accident or by design, the uncertainty of the American position has in some measure prevented the CCP from deciding to reclaim Taiwan.

    I’m looking forward to reading more great posts here!

    Regards,
    Con

Leave a Reply


You must be logged in to post a comment.

[powered by WordPress.]

Free Hao Wu
Keep on Blogging!

Support Bloggers' Rights!
Support Bloggers' Rights!




Search Blog

 
Web AsiaPundit

Archives

July 2005
M T W T F S S
« Jun   Aug »
 123
45678910
11121314151617
18192021222324
25262728293031

Categories

China

Japan

  • Austin Arensberg
    0
  • Black China hand
    0
  • China Confidential
    0
  • China Digital Times (CDT)
    0
  • China e-Lobby
    0
  • China Matters
    0
  • The China Stock Blog
    0
  • Chinese Law Prof Blog
    0
  • Harvard Extended
    0
  • The Horse’s Mouth
    0
  • Isaac Mao
    0
  • serialdeviant.org(y)
    0
  • Shanghai Diaries
    0
  • Howard W French
    0
  • Metanoiac!
    0
  • Danwei
    0
  • supernaut …
    0
  • Bingfeng Teahouse
    0
  • Andrés Gentry
    0
  • sinosplice
    0
  • China Herald
    0
  • Wanbro
    0
  • Running Dog
    0
  • The Unabrewer
    0
  • Shenzhen Ren
    0
  • billsdue
    0
  • the Big Yuan
    0
  • Imagethief
    0
  • middle kingdom stories
    0
  • The LongBow Papers
    0
  • Mandate of Heaven
    0
  • Micah Sittig
    0
  • Survived SARS
    0
  • Under The Tenement Palm
    0
  • Talk Talk China
    0
  • The Paper Tiger
    0
  • T-salon
    0
  • Shanghaiist
    0
  • Wangjianshuo’s Blog
    0
  • Laowiseass
    0
  • Fear of a White Planet
    0
  • Hong Kong

    The Koreas

  • SuaraMalaysia.com
    0
  • Rajan
    0
  • American Expat in SE Asia
    0
  • Pok Ku
    0
  • TV Smith
    0
  • MacVaysia
    0
  • mental jog
    0
  • Screenshots…
    0
  • Nik Nazmi
    0
  • Britishasian
    0
  • Taiwan

  • NiHowdy
    0
  • a better tomorrow
    0
  • betelnutblogger
    0
  • IslaFormosa
    0
  • One whole jujuflop situation
    0
  • Naruwan Formosa
    0
  • Scott Sommers
    0
  • Formosa online
    0
  • Wandering to Tamshui
    0
  • Freedom Slopes
    0
  • Formosa online
    0
  • taiwan tiger 台灣的老虎
    0
  • India & South Asia

    Global & Regional

  • Mutant Frog
    0
  • Sushicam
    0
  • MasaManiA=道徳遊戯
    0
  • Nichi Nichi
    0
  • Tokyo Times
    0
  • Japan Window Photo Blog - Culture, Life, People & Pictures
    0
  • LDK
    0
  • The Tanuki Ramble
    0
  • Frog in a Well
    0
  • Japundit
    0
  • Miyakonojo
    0
  • Joi Ito’s Web
    0
  • The Old Revolution
    0
  • Renegades!
    0
  • Riding Sun
    0
  • Shamrocks!
    0
  • The White Peril 白禍
    0
  • Yagami-Sama
    0
  • Meta Data

    Locations of visitors to this page Listed on BlogShares Ecosystem Details

    Other

    sponsors



    AsiaPundit Friends

    Adopt


    Recommended


    Mr. China - by Tim Clissold:
    How to lose $400 million in the world's biggest market.


    Imelda - Power, Myth, Illusion:
    A documentary on the former Philippine first lady that is damning, sympathetic and incredibly funny.


    Yat Kha - Re Covers:
    Siberian throat-singing punk band searches for its roots


    5.6.7.8.'s - Bomb the Twist:
    Three Japanese women play 1950's-inspired punk.


    Gigantor Box Set Volume 1:
    The original giant Japanese robot


    Mao: The Unknown Story - by Jung Chang and Jon Halliday:
    A controversial and damning biography of the Helmsman.

    Recent Posts

    recent comments

    • tutubi: this is dardn true the 5 peso coins also smuggled out of the country to be melted :(
    • tutubi: you seem to pick up almost any news from here, eh? elections here are generally like that. Candidates (or...
    • Josh: mahathir_fan your an idiot.
    • Inst: don't get arrogant. once this comes to the attention of the authorities who says Opera Mini isn't going to get...
    • Chinese Girl: I think that you all are creeps who are nothing but plain jealous of China. If you think that China is...

    Sponsors

    singapore

    Malaysia

    Indonesia

    Phillippines

    Vietnam

    More from China

    42 queries. 0.923 seconds