The permalink-unfriendly Jakarta Post reports that the Singaporean woman found guilty of negligence in her maid’s death was sentenced to a mere two weeks for the crime. The judge said, “The court will not condone a disregard for the safety of domestic helpers,”:

SINGAPORE (AP): A Singapore court jailed a woman for two weeks for negligence after she ordered her Indonesian maid onto the ledge of an eighth-floor condominium from where she fell to her death, court documents showed.

A district judge said Ngu Mei Mei, 37, who admitted one count of negligence imperiling the life of her maid, Yanti, 22, was sentenced to jail to show that the court would not excuse any thoughtless conduct by employers that placed their maids’ livesin jeopardy.

“The court will not condone a disregard for the safety of domestic helpers,” District Judge Thian Yee Sze wrote in her decision, delivered Tuesday.

“Many of them are very young and come from rural areas, and have never worked in urban areas and high-rise buildings. Hence, they are less aware of the potential dangers,” Thian said.

“It must be remembered that to a foreign domestic helper who is often all alone in Singapore, the employer is not only her superior, whose orders she has to obey, but also her guardian and protector,” the judge wrote.

The woman could have received a maximum sentence of three months in jail, a S$250 (US$150) fine or both. As AsiaPundit said here before, measuring the value of a human life is a tricky business. Although most states and religions regard all men as equals, legal systems generally when considering compensation for wrongful death will look at such things as life expectancy; expected earnings, inflation and a range of other factors.

But beyond that, deterrence has to be considered. For a country as wealthy as Singapore a S$250 for for killing a maid is hardly a deterrent. That can typically just cover dinner and a night at the pub.

Two weeks in jail is not much better. If Singapore judges were not already so well paid, AsiaPundit would mail the sentencing judge a quarter so he could buy himself a clue.

Technorati Tags: asia, east asia, indonesia, singapore, southeast asia